The Greek historian Plutarch famously compared over 40 illustrious Greek and Roman men. This article merely compares two tyrants—Stalin and Mao. Whereas Alexander and Caesar, or Demosthenes and Cicero, lived centuries apart, Stalin and Mao were contemporaries. Rather than recalling their uneasy relationship, this study evaluates and compares three aspects of their performance and misdeeds. As Stalin and Mao were responsible for the deaths of more of their own people than the average tyrant, the study first compares their cruelty and argues that Mao was much less cruel and, second, much less efficient and prone to pursue mutually contradictory aims. Third, he proved more faithful to revolutionary ideals. Two periods during their rule, the Great Terror (1937–38) and the Cultural Revolution, are recalled in order to illustrate the points under discussion.
Citation
Bianco, Lucien. “Comparing Mao to Stalin”. The China Journal. 75, 2016: 83-101. doi.org/10.1086/683126.
Guide for using resource
This journal is published by University of Chicago Press.
Subscription is possible for individuals, institutions, and corporations (for details, please refer to Subscriptions on the individual journal’s website). In addition, individual articles can be bought (usually as a downloadable PDF file).
Some articles are offered as open access.
Proof of personal use may be required, and subscriptions must be purchased with a credit/debit card, or a personal check. Personal rate subscriptions are strictly for personal, non-commercial, use only. The reselling of personal subscriptions is prohibited.
Please check with your institutions if you are already granted institutional access.